Two cookies with a thick layer of filling make a good reason to bring out the dessert plates. These three homemade sandwich cookie recipes give you a few ways to fill them: oatmeal cream pies, dark chocolate cookies with a cream center, and peanut butter oatmeal sandwiches.
Pick a batch for an afternoon of baking or a box to share with a friend. Each recipe has its own cookie texture and filling, so you can choose the one you're most excited to make. A whole plate of filled cookies is a fairly good afternoon plan.
You'll find the recipe credits and direct links below. The full ingredients, baking steps, and storage notes stay with each recipe's creator.
Choose homemade sandwich cookie recipes by the filling
Start with the center. The oatmeal cream pies have vanilla buttercream, the chocolate cookies have a firm cream filling, and the peanut butter recipe offers a peanut butter or fudge option. You can choose one kind for your batch before you shop.
Think about what you want on the plate, too. An oat cookie, a dark cocoa round, and a golden peanut butter cookie give you three different looks. If you're bringing one batch to a gathering, ask what the other bakers have chosen. That leaves room for a few flavors on the table.
For another chocolate option, Happyologie's hot cocoa cookie feature has a marshmallow-topped choice. Keep the sandwich cookies here for the day you want filling all the way through the middle.
Oatmeal cream pies with vanilla buttercream
Sally McKenney's oatmeal cream pies pair soft oat cookies with vanilla buttercream. Cinnamon and molasses are part of the cookie base. This is the pick for a plate of soft, filled cookies in warm brown and cream.
The oat choice matters in this recipe, so read Sally's notes before shopping. Her page also covers cooling, filling, and storage. Keep the sandwiches separate from firmer cookies when you pack them to share.
Sally credits MyRecipes for the cookie base used in her adaptation. This feature links to Sally's version, including her cream filling and recipe notes.
Get Sally McKenney's full oatmeal cream pie recipe.
Chocolate cookies with a thick cream center
Sally McKenney's homemade Oreos put a pale cream filling between dark cocoa cookies. Her recipe uses Dutch-process cocoa. Sally describes crisp edges and a softer middle in her recipe notes.
Choose these for the dark chocolate rounds and the clear stripe of cream. A small stack lets you see both parts at once. They also give a mixed cookie plate a different color beside the golden oat choices.
Read Sally's page for the dough's short chill and the filling instructions. Follow the recipe's cocoa guidance instead of treating every cocoa powder as the same ingredient. That choice belongs to the bake you're making.
Get Sally McKenney's full homemade Oreo recipe.
Peanut butter oatmeal sandwiches with a choice of filling
PJ Hamel's peanut butter-oatmeal sandwich cookies give you two filling options: peanut butter or fudge. King Arthur Baking publishes the recipe. The peanut butter filling is the choice shown here, with golden oat cookies on either side.
This is a useful pick when you want to choose the center before baking. Keep the recipe's filling notes open as you plan your batch. If you choose fudge instead, follow that option's own instructions.
Peanuts are part of this recipe, so name them clearly when you share the cookies. Keep the recipe link with the batch so your friends can check the full ingredients themselves. A handwritten cookie name can sit beside the container.
Get PJ Hamel's full peanut butter-oatmeal sandwich cookie recipe from King Arthur Baking.
Make the batch part of your afternoon plan
Choose your recipe first, then decide what else sounds fun while the cookies cool. You could put on an album, set out a puzzle, or catch up with a friend. Happyologie's things to do at home with friends gives you a few more ideas for the visit.
If you're baking together, check the recipe's tools and kitchen needs before sending the invite. One person can bring an ingredient they already have, while another brings a container for the finished cookies. Agree on that before anyone buys a second bag of the same thing.
Leave room for the recipe's cooling and filling stages when you choose a start time. The end of the oven time isn't always the end of the recipe. Read the full page so you know when the cookies will be ready to pack.
Count and pack the finished sandwiches
For a cookie swap, count one assembled sandwich as one cookie. Each one uses two baked cookies. If your group agrees to bring twelve finished sandwiches, check that your selected recipe makes enough for that share before you shop.
Choose a clean container with room for the finished cookies. Use a separate container for each recipe, and follow the creator's packing and storage notes. If your box needs to stay flat, clear a spot for it before leaving home.
For a shared plate, leave the batches in their own containers until you reach the table. That gives each cookie room on the trip and keeps the ingredient notes with the right batch. You can put a small plate beside each box for serving.
If you're giving the whole batch to one friend, write the cookie name and the baker's name on a card. Add the direct recipe link in your message so they can find it again. A box of cookies and the recipe that inspired it make a thoughtful pair.
Keep the recipe name and link with the box. The FDA's food allergy guidance explains why ingredient information matters. A homemade ingredient card can help someone check a batch, but it doesn't establish that a home kitchen is free from cross-contact.
Ask about food needs before choosing a shared recipe. Let each guest decide what works for them, using the full ingredient information and what they know about their own needs. Keep serving tools with their own batches.
If the filling needs chilled storage, plan for that at home and on the trip. Use the recipe's own guidance. A box with a recipe link tucked inside gives your friend the storage notes and the name of the next batch they might want to make.
You might also like
Pumpkin sugar cookies with spiced buttercream
Plan a soup night with friends
